Login

Sign up

OR

Can't sign in? Did you forget your password?

x

Login


If you don’t have an account, click right here


Can't Sign in? Did you forget your password?

x

Please fill in these details

to create your profile


Click on the image to upload your profile pic

x
x

At Awaremonk, I hereby pledge that

I will not troll or abuse any member of the community.
I will be a good listener.
I will check my facts before stating them and attribute them as well.

x

Forgot Password?

Enter your email and we shall mail you the password reset link

x

Reset Password

Enter new password and confirm password

x
Rajshekhar , student at BITS goa. I am here to learn. Nov, 14 2016

I see everyone with unaccounted money criticizing Modi and everyone paying his/her taxes praising Modi.


I am unable to see any loopholes in the scheme but I see some people here are not completely in favor of the step taken. Can you factually tell what is wrong with the step taken.

Rohit pande , Have a view on many things but happy to thras Nov, 14 2016


Remember, that while this may impoverish some well to do businessmen, no uber rich would become a pauper. Their relative devaluation may sometimes depend on whether they had an inkling either directional or specific of this step. And this includes not just cash notes but also their relative position on Indian real estate.
Remember, that while this may impoverish some well to do businessmen, no uber rich would become a pauper. Their relative devaluation may sometimes depend on whether they had an inkling either directional or specific of this step. And this includes not just cash notes but also their relative position


Rohit pande , Have a view on many things but happy to thras Nov, 14 2016


How similar is this argument to those who think India is intolerant to leave india or is a Paki sympathizer. While its true that a well educated person with good degree in a secure mmc job ( and a paytm wallet to boot ) would only directly lose to the extent of the real estate contraction ( and that too if he has bought a house on mortgage )

but the larger things to discuss are informal sector jobs, the viability of small businesses and the direction of the economy

A sure shot way to kill the debate is to call anyone on the other side a "blackiya". Cant there be an honest taxpayer worried about the economy and fellow citizens ( however misplaced his understanding )

How similar is this argument to those who think India is intolerant to leave india or is a Paki sympathizer. While its true that a well educated person with good degree in a secure mmc job ( and a paytm wallet to boot ) would only directly lose to the extent of the real estate contraction ( and that


Rajshekhar , student at BITS goa. I am here to learn. Nov, 14 2016


I had a simpler point Rohit. Was just talking about my observations.

Also I have not heard a single valid point which can counter the decision made but a lot of criticism, hence I have a bias



Rajshekhar , student at BITS goa. I am here to learn. Nov, 14 2016


If you don't support the move, put forward some valid points. Otherwise it look vague.

For example Kejriwal is saying that there is a sudden increase of money in bank accounts between july-sep. Truth being Govt of India was running a full campaign to encourage people to put unaccounted money in bank ion exchange of just tax and no court case. Intentions of such people come out strongly.



If you don't support the move, put forward some valid points. Otherwise it look vague.For example Kejriwal is saying that there is a sudden increase of money in bank accounts between july-sep. Truth being Govt of India was running a full campaign to encourage people to put unaccounted money in bank


Sahil Khanna , 9 years of experience in running 4 successful Nov, 14 2016


I agree this has disrupted a lot of things at a lot of levels, however this seems to be for a greater good, correct me if i am wrong, this is not the perfect solution but there was no better way to execute this to curb black money for the time being


Rohit pande , Have a view on many things but happy to thras Nov, 14 2016


The point in this thread is different. Are you saying that if someone feels there was a better way or that execution is lacking, is it confirmed that he is a hoarder or black marketeer ? Or could be be entitled to another view and be yet another honest tax payer ?


Sahil Khanna , 9 years of experience in running 4 successful Nov, 14 2016


Yes from my experience everyone who is cribbing about black money somehow is a hoarder, (I am taking a case of more than 30 people around me) and those who are happy are honest tax payers. Indeed its a small set but the results are 100%


Rohit pande , Have a view on many things but happy to thras Nov, 14 2016


And do you think the converse is true ? Means everyone who is lauding it is an honest tax payer. You must have seen the statements of Mr Subhash Chandra saying exactly what you are saying. What does your dip stick say on that ?


Sahil Khanna , 9 years of experience in running 4 successful Nov, 14 2016


Haha! you got me there. Its not a 100% after all, i take my words back. Just realised Ms. Bachchan and Mr. Salman Khan also praising this move, and my logic gets completely flawed there. But as things happen in analytics, are these not outliers, if true data set is considered 'almost' all the hoarder and vice versa.
Haha! you got me there. Its not a 100% after all, i take my words back. Just realised Ms. Bachchan and Mr. Salman Khan also praising this move, and my logic gets completely flawed there. But as things happen in analytics, are these not outliers, if true data set is considered 'almost' all the hoarde


Rohit pande , Have a view on many things but happy to thras Nov, 14 2016


What if they are outliers in volume but not in value


Sahil Khanna , 9 years of experience in running 4 successful Nov, 14 2016


Which is very much possible, take my words back. completely agree with you now (y)